On Being Decisively Indecisive

I want to let you in on a little secret…sometimes I think that I can’t make a decision to save my life. Like literally, if I was hanging off a cliff, I’d probably still be debating my options – would it be better to just take my chances and drop or should I try grabbing for that nearby branch? How about yelling for help? No wait, just how hard is the fall going to be anyway? I mean, if there’s a 50/50 chance, maybe that’s the best thing to do. Hmm…let me just hang here until I figure it out.

It’s the most nonsensical thing about me (well that and my near inability to say no). Both of these things are legacy gifts from my mother. From the time I was a small child, I was programmed to weigh every decision from someone else’s perspective. If I wanted to go to my Granny’s house, my mind would immediately start the chess moves. Does mom want me to go to Granny’s house? If not, how can I get her to want me to go there so that I can go without incident? As I got older, it became an even more complex version of the same game. For everything that I even thought I might want to do, I had to present it to my mom as if I were defending a dissertation, and always, always there would be a zillion questions afterward, all designed to make me NOT WANT this thing that I actually thought I wanted.

So yeah, I have issues with decision making. It’s hard. I know it. I’m working on it. That’s the best I can do right now.

Which brings me to the present.

Every single thing in my life right now requires the one thing that I suck the most at – making and sticking with a decision. My lease is up in less than a month and I need to choose a place to live, but here’s how that internal dialogue goes:

The rent is way too high in XYZ-town and I don’t want to worry about money, but I have friends there and it’s familiar. Yes, but the rent is cheaper in ABC-ville, and it’s just a few hours from XYZ, so you can visit. OH GOD! I won’t know anyone there! And I won’t have my dad and step-mom to go to when I’m feeling down. Maybe I should stay here. I can’t stay here. My mom is here and the last thing I want is to get sucked back into that again. Well, ABC-ville is a just a day’s drive from here, you can come visit. Yes, but will I? And what about that van?? Oh that thingthe van you bought on a whim and now won’t drive because you’re afraid of it breaking down. Well, of course you should sell it! But, I’ve never even camped in it! Who cares, get rid of it. Put the money back in the bank and stop worrying about it. Yes, but…my dad…we’ve connected over that van. Shouldn’t I at least try it out? Nope, everyone but your dad says sell it, so that’s how it’s gotta be.

So last week I put the van up for sale and put a deposit on a place in ABC-ville. This week, my application for the apartment in ABC-ville got approved and I took the van off-line and started making curtains for it. The other night, I got a message from someone who saw the van when it was online and was interested in buying it, but instead of telling him “no, sorry”, I answered him back and told him to let me know what worked best for a test drive. Then the next morning I got up wondering if moving to ABC-ville was even what I really wanted to do.

Usually when I have difficult decisions to make, I make a list of the pros and cons (I did that) and then, after all the talking and debating, I just go with my gut. My gut is usually the best indicator of what I truly want, but my gut has been wrenched into a pretzel and it’s not functioning properly at all right now. It wants to choose comfort over courage, and that might be alright, except that in this time when I shouldn’t be making any major decisions, I have to. There’s no option not to, because even if I say screw it all, I’m doing something entirely different than any of this, that’s a decision, and I have to figure out what that looks like before the 24th day of September.

But the thing is, I don’t want to start a whole new life. I like the one I worked to build already. I didn’t like what it became here in Tennessee, with my mom controlling so much of it, and I certainly don’t like what has happened with me and Angie, or the fact that I feel unable to decide anything anymore, but there’s still so much I do like. And so much I still want to do. And a lot of things I just simply want to do better.

So, the other night I did something I haven’t done in nearly 20 years. I sat down in a chair and talked out loud (or prayed, if you will) to the Universe (or God) for direction and guidance. I tried to unburden my heart of all the weight I was carrying and I wish that I could say that I felt it lifting or that I knew which choice to make, but you already know that’s not the case. I do understand that it takes time. I also understand that every decision made can just as easily be unmade. (I’m probably an expert on that particular topic actually.) I understand fear and how it makes you powerless to act. But I’m not sure these things are the problem. Because the one thing that I walked away with from my chat with the Universe was yet another question:

For whom am I trying to make these decisions in the first place?

It was as if someone had looked over my pros and cons list and made notes (with a red pen, of course) in the margins that said, “where are YOU in all this?” And honestly, I don’t know.

For years, I allowed a toxic person to dictate my life and I felt powerless to do anything about it…because that toxic person was my mother. It has been 39 days today since I last spoke to her, and as incredibly hard as I always thought it would be to walk away from her, it just hasn’t been. I’m not going to pretend that I made that decision all on my own and I’m certainly not discounting the fact that it took a bomb going off in my life to make it happen, but the lightness I feel not being around her is something I would never have expected. The doors that have opened since, I would not have expected either. And the fact that of all the decisions I’m agonizing over right now, she is not one of them, speaks volumes to me. Yes, it was a painful process. It’s still a painful process, trying to unlearn these learned behaviors that my mom so thoughtfully gifted me.

Maybe that’s the real lesson in all this. Maybe I’m the one overcomplicating things (again). Maybe what happens next isn’t going to be anything I would have expected. And maybe that’s okay.

Maybe I can’t decide what to do with the van or where to live because these seemingly big decisions might be small things to other people, but because I’m me, I think the fate of the world rests in each one. So maybe, I just need to take a step back and look at the wider view. Because when all is said and done, van or no van, ABC or XYZ, these are my decisions to make and I have to make them for me.

9 thoughts on “On Being Decisively Indecisive

    1. You didn’t miss anything. I talked about it briefly on another blog but I haven’t really said anything concrete here. I guess I was waiting to see, but it’s been almost 2 months now. Angie and I are living apart right now. I don’t know if right now is forever, because well, frankly forever is a freakin’ long time to predict what’s going to happen. My mom’s behavior, over the past year especially, put us both through the wringer and she felt we needed time to get our heads together separately. She’s still my very best friend and I have nothing but respect for her.

      Liked by 1 person

  1. Which path do you feel more excited or hopeful about? If money wasn’t an issue, which path would you choose? How much of an issue is it? Can there be ways to mitigate it? I like the path where I feel excited – where things are new – if that path is possible. Good luck whatever way you go, and I hope you have a good day today.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I sat down today and put all my options through what I’m now calling the ‘Betty Test’ (thank you very much for the wonderful questions!). I scored all of them, including some I hadn’t allowed myself to consider, on an excitement scale of 1-10 and despite being the most practical option, the location where I was accepted for an apartment, scored a 2. The most exciting is, of course, the most expensive but I’ve started brainstorming some very creative ways I could make this work. Thank you again!! Have a great evening!

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Once again my life is similar to yours. I’ve wanted to move to another town for years, my mom controlled my life for forever and now I’m free. My decision making process is same as yours, pros and cons for staying versus leaving. Staying here is easiest as my house is paid off but moving would give me the change I think I need, commute to work almost same distance but not a straight foreword commute. I could easily stay where I’m at and quit my job which I’ve longed to do because I’m tired of the commute and my boss is a turd. But I’m good at my job and I’m paid well for this area. See? Daily I go over this in my head. Move, pay rent or buy another house, rent is kinda high where I want to live and major downsizing would need to commence. However rent will be paid with money from sale of moms house. So why worry, right? One and on it goes. I would have to buy a condo because housing prices too high where I want to go but do I really want to buy another house? The one I’m in took several years to get it to the stage I wanted it. I’m not feeling the urge to start that process again so renting is the answer, right? Again daily I have this argument in my head. I wish you the best, please keep posting on your process. I feel much more “normal” knowing I’m not the only one who struggles with decisions. I also have made decisions that I’ve turned back around because I changed my mind once the process started. I wear myself out. Good luck my friend!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yep, I’m worn out right along with you! There are too many ifs, ands, and buts when it comes to sorting through all of this ‘where to live’ business. Maybe the right answers will come soon enough for both of us. Hang in there!


  3. Your post so resonated with me so much!!! sometimes I cannot make and stick to decisions as well. And I do make a list of cons and pros to look at the situation with a logical frame, and also talking to someone surely brings some sort of clarity about everything. So, all great form my perspective 🙂 Sometimes we cannot stick to a plan, because deep down we know that is not the best plan, so be kind with yourself when this happens. I find that if I feel consistently the same way about a plan over a time/a couple of days, then it is likely the best plan, rather than a knee-jerk kind of reactive plan (do you know what I mean). Also the question you asked WHERE AM I IN ALL OF THESE? yes, indeed….you are a gem – be kind with yourself and thank you for sharing these with us. All the best and virtual hugs – everything will be okay 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I know exactly what you mean! Most of my decisions here lately have been of the knee-jerk reactive variety. Thank you so much for your kind words and virtual hugs! I needed that, along with the reminder to trust those feeling that seem to be saying this is not the right plan (no matter how much I try to force it to be).🙂

      Liked by 1 person

Let us know what you think...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.